Eataly, the expansive Italian marketplace with two popular New York locations, opened its doors in New Jersey Wednesday, launching a new spot at Short Hills Mall.
Not only will customers be able to shop among the aisles of breads, cheeses, and pasta, they’ll also be able to dine in the 230-seat restaurant and bar, Eataly Ristorante. There are now more than 50 Eataly locations worldwide.
Kicking off the first of 10 days of special events, Eataly held a grand opening. It welcomed a small group to peek inside its new 17,000-square-foot space and try some of the Italian cuisine and wines.
Here are the five best things we ate during the opening:
5. Raspberry gelato
Raspberry Gelato at Eataly at at The Mall at Short Hills at Short Hills, NJMurjani Rawls
With many food options at your fingertips, sometimes you have to start with the desserts. The gelato station at Short Hills offers more than 20 flavors, and I tried the Raspberry. It was not as tart as expected. It was so flavorful and not as sweet. Rumor has it the passionfruit flavor is also superb. Since I only had one sample, I will have to go back soon!
4. 24-month parmigiano reggiano
24-Month parmigiano reggiano at Eataly at at The Mall at Short Hills at Short Hills, NJMurjani Rawls
With the 24-month parmigiano cheese, we watched a cheese monger cut it right before us. The portions I received were big chunks, easy to pair with crackers or your favorite charcuterie. It was everything you want from your parm: potent, salty, a bit sweet. This is one of the many aged cheeses they sell in-store
3. Soppressata pizza alla pala
Soppressata Pizza Alla Pala at Eataly at at The Mall at Short Hills at Short Hills, NJMurjani Rawls
Out of all the samples of pizza alla pala (oval shaped flatbreads served on a paddle), the soppressata style was by far my favorite. The combination of the flavorful soppressata with a tiny kick and the chewiness of the dough brought it home for me. Whole pies and slices will be available to purchase.
2. Tiramisu
Tiramisu at Eataly at Mall at Short Hills at Short Hills, NJMurjani Rawls
The best dessert was the tiramisu, which might make you want to buy a tub of it. Our sample sizes offered an excellent mixture of cocoa powder and ladyfingers. The coffee taste is strong, doesn’t overwhelm the sweetness. There was just the right amount of sugar.
1. Cacio e pepe
Cacio E Pepe At Eataly at The Mall At Short Hills At Short Hills, NJMurjani Rawls
It may seem like cacio e pepe is a simple pasta dish, but it’s a collision of flavor done right. I appreciated the richness of the cheese combined with the black pepper, where each ingredient’s boldness complemented one another. Expect to see this on the Eataly restaurant menu.
Looking for even more New Jersey food coverage? Subscribe to the free Jersey Eats newsletter here.
Related coverage:
- A legendary N.J. pizza maker just announced his next pop-up. Here are the details.
- Beloved N.J. Italian deli and bakery to close after nearly 50 years
- New Jersey’s 37 best Italian delis, ranked for 2024
Our journalism needs your support. Please subscribe today to NJ.com.
Murjani Rawls may be reached at mrawls@njadvancemedia.com and followed on Twitter at @MurjaniRawls.